Exploring transformative learning and the courage to teach a values based curriculum
Section snippets
What is values based learning
Values-Based Learning (VBL) emphasises aesthetic knowing to develop human attributes conducive to the support of well-being. It seems obvious to state that VBL has a lot to offer nursing students and nursing education, considering that nursing has long been venerated for being an art. However, over recent years arts-based learning has been left languishing, in part because of the rise of ideologies such as techno-rationalism and bio-medicalism and the subsequent over-valorisation of practices
The foundations of transformative learning
Transformative Learning (TL) comes within the umbrella concept of critical pedagogy, a philosophy for teaching and learning that aims for radical social action so that entrenched social inequities are questioned and if needed, replaced (Brookfield, 2005). Briefly, Transformative Learning is that which seeks to expand a student's consciousness so that existing world views and self-perceptions are re-considered (Cranton, 2006). Such a pedagogy fits the intentions of nursing much better than
Rethinking values
The idea that ‘today's students' are missing the important values base needed to competently care is not new, but it is certainly a common complaint. Writers in the popular and scholarly press have frequently bemoaned the lack of one particular value – compassion – in the health service, and often nurses are blamed (or scapegoated) and subsequently so are students and the education system. The implications are that graduates are inherently deficient, lacking attributes with which others – such
The disappearing care dilemma
To assist learners to achieve perspective transformation, they first need to be aware of disorienting dilemmas. According to Mezirow (2000) an unprocessed disorienting dilemma is paralysing and can lead to a feeling of hopelessness and inaction. But when the dilemma is intellectually processed through reflection, dialogue, planning new courses of action, and practice, the learner can experience hopefulness and liberty in action.
One important disorienting dilemma for students is one that has
Inequalities amongst patients continue
Another insidious binary that continues to constrain the delivery of equitable and ethical health care to people, is the idea of there being deserving and undeserving patients (Tarlier, 2004). It may not be a consciously held value, but students may learn in clinical practice that some patients are treated unequally and judgements are made about them which are stigmatising, dehumanising and lead to negative health and social outcomes. This is argued because studies continue to reveal that
Knowing what to teach transformatively
There are specific, teachable concepts and acts that can assist student nurses to think about and deliver care that is not only based on technical competence but also on an explicit foundation of current nursing values. Teaching to transform is all about taking the time to engage and sensitize students to issues that need changing, but which may have become embedded, taken for granted, not noticed, or perhaps something one feels helpless to change. Once sensitized, students are ready to learn
Knowing how to teach transformatively
Because TL rests in the discourse of critical theory, which posits that understanding without change is meaningless, it follows that students learning nursing through this pedagogy need to have their learning mobilised and their knowledge put into action. Aesthetic learning has this mobilising potential (Brien and McAllister, in press).
Within the discourse known as narrative medicine, there is great value placed on health professionals developing a ‘sense of the aesthetic’, because it develops
Conclusion
This paper has argued the value of a pedagogy for nursing that moves beyond a preoccupation with techniques and medical knowledge, but also does not dismiss this learning. Transformative Learning has a hopeful vision, one that sees change is possible, it is occurring, and we can play a part in hastening, or facilitating this movement. Changes made by students do not have to be monumental for them to be significant and long lasting. Students who are equipped and confident to make change are
Acknowledgement
A version of this paper was presented as the key note address at the NETNEP conference in Noorwijkerhout, the Netherlands, in June 2014.
References (34)
- et al.
Leadership for Personalization and Social Inlusion in Mental Health
(2009) - et al.
Educating Nurses: a Call for Radical Transformation
(2009) - et al.
The anaesthetized aesthetic: releasing the educative potential of eating disorder memoirs
Educ. Philos. Theory
(2015) The Power of Critical Theory Liberating Adult Learning and Teaching
(2005)- et al.
‘Things you can't learn from books': teaching recovery from a lived experience perspective
Int. J. Ment. Health Nurs.
(2013) Narrative medicine: a model for empathy, reflection, profession and trust
J. Am. Med. Assoc.
(2001)Understanding and Promoting Transformative Learning: a Guide for Educators of Adults
(2006)Thinking for a Living: How to Get Better Performance and Results from Knowledge Workers
(2005)- et al.
The Roots of the Recovery Movement in Psychiatry: Lessons Learned
(2010) Images, transformative learning and the work of soul
Adult Learn.
(2001)
The impact of stigma in healthcare on people living with chronic illnesses
J. Health Psychol.
Pedagogy of the Oppressed
Values-based practice: help and healing within a shared theology of diversity
The rise and fall of the biopsychosocial model
Br. J. Psychiatry
Teaching as possibility: a light in dark times
The concept of praxis
Young Nurses 'too Posh to Wash
Cited by (15)
Intercultural readiness of nursing students: An integrative review of evidence examining cultural competence educational interventions
2021, Nurse Education in PracticeCitation Excerpt :However, Lin et al. (2015) and Gallagher and Polanin (2015) warn of the risks of cultural competence diminishing overtime, suggesting the need to re-examine ways of developing the intercultural readiness of nursing students. Greater consideration needs to be given not just to the content of nursing curricula, but also the educational philosophies and methodologies used in the cultural competence preparation of nursing students (McAllister, 2015; Almutairi et al., 2017). Two systematic reviews examining the effectiveness of cultural competence training for registered nurses found that such interventions increased practitioners confidence, enhanced the quality of care provided and improved patient satisfaction (Clifford et al., 2015; Govere and Govere, 2016).
Acknowledging the primacy of continuity of care experiences in midwifery education
2020, Women and BirthNurturing cultural competence in nurse education through a values-based learning approach
2019, Nurse Education in PracticeHome students’ experiences of intercultural learning: A qualitative descriptive design
2019, Nurse Education TodayCitation Excerpt :Interestingly, there was little emphasis placed on the need to understand themselves as well as the way in which they create relationships with people from other cultures. Cultural knowledge alone does not ensure sensitivity; however a lack of knowledge can contribute to insensitive attitudes and behaviours (McAllister, 2015; Markey et al., 2018a). This study highlights the need for learning and teaching approaches that extend beyond development of cultural specific knowledge in isolation, but does not dismiss the value of such information.
An Evidence-based Approach to Measuring Affective Domain Development
2019, Journal of Professional NursingCitation Excerpt :The development of attitudes, values, motivation, beliefs, and emotions (Savickienė, 2010); more importantly affective domain measurement is the focus of this paper. The transformation of nursing education across different countries calls for evidence-based pedagogies that address professional values acquisition (Benner, Sutphen, Leonard, & Day, 2010; McAllister, 2015; Willis, 2012). Current evidence on affective domain development provides thoughts on learning interventions but fails to address the need for evidence based educational interventions (Taylor, 2014).
Professional values in student nurse education: An integrative literature review
2022, Nursing Ethics